It is a scam if we give someone something and get nothing in return. But not always. Sometimes we give something away with no expectation of return, and that is called charity, and not a scam at all. So where does the billions of dollars of aid that the United States gives to Africa fit into that equation? There has been a re-examination of that aid due to the massive amount of attention received by Dambisa Moyo, often referred to as the “anti-Bono.” Moyo is a leading economist and policy maker in the United States and served as the head of Economic Research and Strategy for Sub-Saharan Africa. (www.brookings.edu/articles) She is the author of Dead Aid, hence her comparison to Bono.
She argues in her book that Western aid to Africa, a pet topic of mine over the past year, has not only perpetuated poverty but also worsened it. She points to China to support her argument where there are 3.1 billion people. Forty years ago, China was poorer than many African countries. Today they have money that they earned from what they built, working hard to create a system where they were not dependent on aid. China now lends money to the United States. She believes that aid to Africa has held it back. “You get corruption-historically, leaders have stolen money without penalty- and you get dependency, which kills entrepreneurship. You also disenfranchise African citizens, because the government is beholden to foreign donors and not accountable to its own people” Moyo argues. (www.NYTimes/Questionsfor)
What she recommends in lieu of charity is to microfinance – to give people jobs. That resonated particularly with me because she cites Kiva (www.Kiva.org) as a suitable place to begin to truly help Africa. Kiva has been targeted in the past year by my own charitable foundation, (www.MyronGushlakFoundation.com)
Anyone who has spent any time parenting knows that this is a central dilemma. When to help and when to stand by and let your child fall. At some point, the offer of aid becomes a weapon creating a dependency that will guarantee compliance with what the giver wants to get in return. Aid can “buy” political compliance, as well as pave the way for favorable trade terms for the giver. So the original question stands, is it charity or is it a scam?
By Myron Gushlak
